What a weekend of professional wrestling.
Brock Lesnar Vs Omos
The freak show match delivered. Brock put on a great 5 minute sell job as Omos worked over his back to hold off the inevitable Brock win. I enjoyed the back giving up on the first F5 attempt to make the eventual F5 come off as a bigger feat of strength, and only doing it once helped it feel more of a special spot. An improvement on both men's last Wrestlemania matches, and a better opener than Cena/Theory the night before, and you can't ask for much more than that out of Brock Lesnar Vs Omos.
Ronda Rousey and Shayna Vs Natalya and Shotzi Vs Liv and Raquel Vs Chelsea and Sonya
On paper this looked to be the weakest match across both nights of Wrestlemania and that's exactly how it ended up. Not only are there no real stakes here, but the winner felt predictable and the work was never gonna live up to the wild action the men's 4 way tag put on the night earlier. Liv and Raquel felt like the team with fun chemistry which they'd be better served pushing as babyface tag champions down the line, and Chelsea's act is mildly entertaining, but that's about the limit of the nice things I can say about this match. Ronda winning after doing pretty much nothing all match felt completely undeserved, but hey WWE are merging with UFC so I get it.
Gunther Vs Sheamus Vs Drew McIntyre
I didn't watch the 2000s indies in real time, so that emotional 'you made it' pride that other fans had when Daniel Bryan, Kevin Owens or Sami Zayn made Wrestlemania main events doesn't connect as stronger with me as it does with others. I definitely have that pride with Gunther who over the last decade I've seen go from wXw to the UK indies, to the US indies to NXT UK and now WWE main roster and get over everywhere and put on phenomenal matches where he's giving guys their career best bouts. I'm thrilled that his career has come this far and the trajectory is still firmly upwards.
I love how after 14 years in this company, Sheamus still has targets to strive for that the crowd are invested in. His chase for the Intercontinental Championship to complete the set has been a great mid-card story that fell into WWE's laps last year and I hope he keeps chasing it for years to come. It'll feel like a great 'golden watch' moment when he does win it.
I like Drew McIntyre too.
A few years ago NXT Takeovers were the safest bet in WWE because they always delivered. Gunther matches now have that honour because they never miss. This match was incredible, all three guys beat the shit out of each other in a weekend stealing match that's been a pretty stacked weekend to steal. We were all Cole, Graves and Titus getting giddy over the brutal action. Apart from that Gunther splash out of nowhere to break up Sheamus and Drew fighting for a few minutes, this didn't feel like the typical WWE triple threat where two guys fight and one waits on the outside for his spot to return. Tremendous nearfalls in this one, crucially with Sheamus coming close to winning the title as that's where the fan interest was. Awesome, awesome, awesome match.
If I had the book, I'd be calling up Ilja Dragunov to win this title from Gunther to put those career rivals back together.
Ed's Ongoing 2023 MOTY List
Bianca Belair Vs Asuka
I felt a bit bad for these two following the triple threat, but I had no reason to be because they also knocked it out the park. Asuka's look is possibly the best facepaint work in wrestling history. Bianca really comes off like the female John Cena with her entrance, that was adorable with the dancing kids. We know from her NXT days that Bianca can be a great heel and that would be a way to breath fresh life into this long title run, but I'm hoping they stick the course as she's a great fan favourite, the type of female ace Bayley could have been on the main roster. Anyway back to the match, Mrs. Wrestlemania does it again, and this one really played into the unpredictability in the result. Bianca's been champion for so long now that it was probably time to put the title on someone else and tell a different story for a bit, but at the same time it's clear to see who the company is higher on between her and Asuka, so I was biting on pretty much everything in that fantastic closing stretch after the mist-miss. That whole sequence played into the back and forth struggle for control the two of them showcased all match. Rather like the Sasha match 2 years earlier, they made a point to have spots designed to put over Bianca's strength. They weren't quite as memorable as the walking up the stairs gorilla press on Sasha, but powerbomb on the outside, the superplex back into the ring and the deadlift KOD at the end were all top notch spots. I thought last year was a down year for womens wrestling in the states with only two womens matches making my top 25 list for the year, but WWE's offerings this weekend were fantastic and I'm sure they'll be better represented in my list this year.
Ed's Ongoing 2023 MOTY List
Edge Vs Finn Balor
The early brownie points this match gained for Edge's Slayer introduction and the surprise return of the original cell design were quickly lost by Balor's goofy smoke grenade entrance and the purple painted weapons as if he's Harchester United's biggest fan. We get it, you like the colour purple. This was a fine plunder match which tbf the weekend was light on so it offered up something different. I enjoyed the New Day/Usos spot where Balor got trapped in the corner with the kendo sticks, although that doesn't work quite as well in a singles match as it does a tag setting where it leads to a numbers advantage. Despite Edge's bug eyed facials, I never got a sense of hatred in this one, moreso just your standard WWE feud blow off match. Hellacious ladder throw by Edge, that was both the highlight and lowlight of the match. In the moment the blood stoppage was really lame and stopped all the momentum it had, however seeing the sheer size of Finn's gash I understand why the match had to be halted for him to get numbing agent and staples to continue. Convenient step built into the cell aside, the coup de grace through the table miss was a good spot. I think I'd rather have Edge win straight away with the spear follow up on that one. The match wasn't as bad as I was dreading, but I think I enjoyed just about every match other than the 4 way tag more than this one.
The Miz Vs Shane McMahon and Snoop Dogg
This was the best comedy segment WWE has ever produced, and it happened by complete accident. Shane McMahon's surprise return completely works given his recent history with Miz at Wrestlemania but Shane blowing out his knee took a toilet break segment to goat tier in split seconds. Snoop Dogg asking Shane 'you alright cuz?' as he laid their like his father at Royal Rumble 2005 had me howling. Quick thinker Snoop then punched Miz in the face a couple of times and then delivered a people's elbow to get a win over Miz. What brilliant improvising from Snoop to save this segment from being a car crash - I can still vividly rememeber 4 veteran professional wrestlers being unable to work a match on the fly at Elimination Chamber 2015 when Mark Henry's pod malfunctioned, and here's Snoop calm as anything completing saving the day when the unthinkable has happened. What an entertainer. Much better than the Pat McAfee segment the night before. We will never forget where we were when Shane McMahon tried to yet again win his fathers love and failed in the most hilarious, poetic way possible.
Roman Reigns Vs Cody Rhodes
A match that feels totally overshadowed by the result. I'll do my best to break down both elements. Firstly the quality of the match which I thought was excellent. This has obviously been a long reign with a wide variety of challengers, but I thought this was the best match Roman's had in the last 2 1/2 years. Heel Roman Reigns clearly has a formula to his matches - early domination, babyface comeback, insecurities seep in, initial bloodline interference, babyface survives, 2nd wave of bloodline interference, spear and Roman wins. It's a plug in a play formula that always produces a good main event to close out the show, and there's nothing wrong with that. To use this years Hollywood tag-line for a minute, so many movie franchises have a plug in a play formula from James Bond to Scream to MCU money grabbers and it works for them. The key is executing that formula well and Roman, Cody and Heyman all performed their roles superbly well. Roman's aura and body language in-between the moves is unrivalled, no-one has a better presence than he does in the industry right now, Cody had everyone in the building believing in his dream and he nailed all his hope spots, and Heyman was perfect as a went through a rollercoaster of emotions throughout the contest. What put this match over the top as the best heel Roman title match yet was the feeling of this being the end (even though it wasn't). Solo being thrown out early meant we knew The Usos would then come out, but then having Kevin and Sami come out to make the save was a great moment that fit the story and finally meant a Roman challenger was finishing a match on a level playing field. This was the way everyone hoped and expected the historic title reign to end to put a cap on a fantastic weekend of wrestling.
And then we all got worked because Solo came back out, stabbed his thumb into Cody's throat and cost him the match. Rather like Wrestlemania 17, an all timer event ends with a flat finish for the fans to digest. At the time I hated the finish and felt like they'd made a mistake because they'd never have a hotter moment to make the switch and it felt like the time to move onto a different story after nearly 3 years of this. After 2 days to mull it over, I've come around to at least understanding the decision and feeling like it wasn't a mistake. Here's the reasons why:
1) Cody isn't the right choice to end the reign, especially at this point in time. He has hardly been involved in this story as half his mania build up was overshadowed with Sami Zayn's story with The Bloodline. Not only that, but his chase has been too quick and without struggle kayfabe wise (injury aside but they couldn't script for that). He shows back up after years away and beats Seth 3-0 over their feud, then wins the Rumble at #30, cuts a couple of promos about his dad and then he's supposed to win the title from Roman. I'm not sure that's a good enough build up on his side of things to be the one that ends this historic run. Cody already feels like a top star on this roster so he doesn't need the title to 'make him', and I feel like there are more interesting directions he can go in first before becoming world champion and realising his dream. Namely a feud with Brock which was the only interesting thing to come out of Raw on Monday. Finish the story? It's too soon for that. If, and it's a big if, Jey Uso is the one to end Roman's run, then that's a more fitting end to this 3 year story because it all started with Jey and his emotional torment has been the throughline across it all. If the Bloodline slowly dissolve over 2023, that's a believable way for Roman to struggle more in his title matches and eventually lose.
2) They've come this far, they might as well reach 1,000 days as we'll never see anything like this again. I'm sure there's an event being held on that 1,000th day so they can market the hell out of that
3) Should you end such a historic reign within the same 24 hour period the company is going to announce the even more historic news that they're selling to Endevour? Cody Rhodes would have been demoted to 2nd biggest story of the weekend had he won on Sunday night, so maybe they want to hold off until they can milk a title win for the maximum publicity.
4) I really have to push back on this idea that WWE are fumbling their booking because they keep having Roman win. Not only is it a continuation of them finally pushing Roman right, which previously was a big criticism people had of WWE booking Roman's babyface runs wrong, but this feud keeps getting better and better. If WWE didn't 'fumble' Drew McIntyre in Cardiff, we wouldn't have gotten the great Logan Paul match in Saudi Arabia and we wouldn't have gotten the Sami stuff from Wargames to Royal Rumble which felt like WWE's biggest angle in a generation. If WWE didn't 'fumble' Sami Zayn in Montreal, you wouldn't have the amazing scenes on Saturday when Sami and Kevin won the title in the main event of Wrestlemania Saturday, and we wouldn't have gotten Roman Vs Cody which is on of the best main events in mania history. Over the last 7 months this run has really peaked for Roman with great matches and hot angles, and while I'll accept some of that has to be down to it's mania season and fans are excited because the end might be in sight, there's enough proof there that WWE know how to build up new challengers for Roman to keep things interesting, and that those that fall to Roman are still in good shape to deliver elsewhere on the card (which Drew, Logan, Owens, Sami and Cody all are)
As I say at the moment it's still hard to separate this match and the booking decision along with it, but I hope as time goes on we'll be able to look back at this match fondly as one of the best in Roman's run and one of the better mania main events of all time.
Ed's Ongoing 2023 MOTY List